Skip to content
Now Available: Threat Detection, Defense & Remediation using ASM | Read Now
Blog

CVE-2021-20090: Where the Buffalo Get Owned

Share

August 16, 2021

Summary

On August 3rd, Tenable Security disclosed a vulnerability in a line of residential routers from Buffalo Technologies using firmware developed by Arcadyan. Three days later, researchers confirmed that attackers were actively exploiting vulnerable devices in an attempt to deploy malware.

Analysis

As of August 12th, Censys identified 4,378 devices that match the fingerprint that Tenable published. Arcadyan devices respond with several distinguishing properties, including unique header values in HTTP responses and several SSL certificates, including:

Running a Censys certificate analysis on these three fingerprints confirms these certificates share common values and allow us to search for hosts in broader terms:

Most common certificate analysis

Given that many of the reports coming in are claiming that “millions” of devices are affected, it’s evident that Censys was only able to find a tiny fraction of these hosts listening on the public internet.

Since these manufacturers deal primarily in Europe and East Asia, devices Censys identified were in the areas seen in the geographic heatmap below.

In the following tables, we can see the majority of these devices are located in Japan (57% with 2,534 hosts), Spain (11% with 522 hosts), and Argentina (7% with 320 hosts)..

Location Hosts
Japan 2,534 57.88%
Spain 522 11.92%
Netherlands 320 7.31%
Argentina 300 6.85%
Germany 278 6.35%
United Kingdom 96 2.19%
Australia 68 1.55%
Italy 38 0.87%
Russia 38 0.87%
Czechia 27 0.62%
other 157 3.59%
Total 4,378 100.0%

Full Timeline of Events

Initially, Tenable researchers reported the vulnerability to a single vendor, Buffalo, who confirmed the issue on February 24th and escalated to Buffalo’s office in Japan. It was around this time when Tenable discovered the vulnerability was not specific to Buffalo, but rather any device using firmware developed by the manufacturer Arcadyan.

Tenable researchers found the vulnerable code in a programming library shared across multiple vendors used by 13 ISPs across 11 countries and has been vulnerable for an estimated ten years.

Vulnerable devices can be compromised using a simple directory traversal exploit, allowing an attacker to modify the device’s configuration to enable shell access and bypass the authentication step altogether. Tenable has posted a detailed article on the entire exploitation process here.

Arcadyan confirmed the issues on April 25th and informed Tenable that a patch was in the works. When Tenable asked for a list of affected devices, Arcadyan went silent, and as it turns out, that list was rather extensive.

On August 5th, the threat-intel company Bad Packets posted the following tweet, asserting that they had witnessed attackers scanning for vulnerable Buffalo routers:

On August 6th, just three days after the report went public, Juniper Threat Labs confirmed that the bug is being actively used by a group of attackers who have executed similar attacks on home networking devices in the past to install the IoT botnet malware Mirai.

we have identified some attack patterns that attempt to exploit this vulnerability in the wild coming from an IP address located in Wuhan, Hubei province, China.

Juniper Threat Labs

Why does it matter?

Now that Juniper has confirmed attackers are attempting to use this vulnerability to install the Mirai botnet, unprotected devices may be unwittingly scanning and attacking other hosts, participating in orchestrated distributed denial of service attacks, and engaging in fraudulent activities.

What’s most alarming about this whole mess is the amount of time between public disclosure and confirmed active exploitation. Security research is not a one-way mirror, and when it comes to vulnerability discovery, always assume the bad-actors are monitoring the same intel feeds as defenders.

What do I do about it?

The list of vulnerable devices is still growing, and details are still emerging on the malware front. We cannot assume the average internet user keeps up with security trends and actively participates in patch management. The only remedy is a clear line of communication between service providers and their customers to upgrade these devices promptly.

  • Immediately upgrade any devices you own that are found in CERT’s growing list of affected vendors.
  • Assure all networking devices have up-to-date software.
  • Do not expose router administration interfaces to the internet.
  • Continually monitor your infrastructure manually with Censys Search, or automatically using Censys ASM to identify unintentionally exposed ports and services.


References

About the Author
Mark Ellzey
Senior Security Researcher All posts by Mark Ellzey
Mark Ellzey is a Senior Security Researcher at Censys. Before his current role, Mark has worked as both a network security engineer and software developer for several internet service providers and financial institutions for over 22 years.
Attack Surface Management Solutions
Learn more